List of sellers selling genuine signed (trustworthy) or NON-genuine signed kpop albums (autographed)

, , 209 comments


Hello!

Here is a list (with some comments I have added) of GENUINE signed albums sellers and non genuine signed albums sellers!
I have been on eBay -a bit too long- so I've started to know who is legit and who's not. On the first glance with no experience, it is a tricky job and we tend to be fooled by the positive feedbacks the seller has and the amount of transactions he had, BUT people who have no real knowledge are the ones to get fooled and are unaware that they dealt with a scammer! I will only list the sellers' names, as for the links I am sure you can find them yourself! I will also write a little about sellers I have bought from.

This list only tells you whether X seller sells a genuine album. Sellers in the trustworthy section are 99% going to sell a genuine signed album (they are humans after all and mistakes may happen, they tend to make sure what they are selling is genuine, and it is possible they may sell a signed album by a manager - I have seen it a lot for Exo, so you'd have to analyze, like 1-2signatures can be from the actual members and the rest by the manager), and sellers in the untrustworthy section are selling fake signed albums. Whether the fake signed albums sellers does a good job or not sending/packing your order has nothing to do with this list, this list is just to tell you if you indeed bought something signed from them, it won't be genuine. If you have purchased something not signed, I won't know whether this seller does a good job being a simple seller.


TRUSTWORTHY (sells genuine)

May I state that the Exo signed albums of any of the ebay sellers are almost all signed by their managers. The sellers get them from trustworthy sources (broadcast) but it's just the managers' work. HOWEVER, some exo signed albums might be signed by both manager and exo members. Like for the EXO-CBX album, I have seen an album signed by Chen, and the other two members' signatures were signed by the manager. We can't control anything about that ):

EBAY SELLERS

Grapemusiccd
I last ordered two signed albums from him 6 months ago, so I can't quite recall if it was sent in a bubble envelope or a box (I think it was a box?), and it was well protected, everything was damage free, bubble wrapper and some air bags if my memory is not too horrible (I regret not writing this earlier). The albums were protected in transparent sleeves, to avoid surely the two albums getting smashed together and getting their signatures printed onto the other one. He offers really good prices, I feel like he even offers lower prices than the general market majority of times. Overall: good protection, good service. His English is not perfect, but he will try to answer you the best he can.
Handdollmaking
Ipkorea
Jace0337
Kr-Monster
Very professional seller, I bought once an album from him, and although I was surprised to see my album arrive in a bubble envelope, inside there was plenty of bubble wrapper, like a good 3-4 layers, and he also gave some fanmade goodies which is always a nice bonus to receive.
Kshop4u
Mojasajo 
Honestly one of my favorite ebay sellers, his English is very fluent, so there isn't any language barrier and he is very friendly, even when you have never purchased anything from him and sort of wasted his time! His packaging is really neat, with newspaper, and plenty of bubble wrapper, the quality and service is surely there! He also ships very quickly the orders!
Quietrio
Thejellyhouse


PLEASE DO NO FORGET THAT SM ARTISTS ALBUMS ARE MOST LIKELY SIGNED BY MANAGERS. (so not signed by the idols themselves)

WEBSITE PLATFORMS

Mwave
The cheapest place and the most 100% secure place to buy from! This is a website of one of the broadcast stations korean singers go on: Mnet. There were several different opinions about their packaging, however I only received once a slightly damaged album out of the 456734257674 times I bought from them, but after that incident (it actually happened to me on my first purchase and the album only had one layer of bubble wrap and a poor cardboard), they always sent me packages with good cardboard and a good 2-3 layers of bubble wrap.
YesAsia
Only purchased once from them, I received my two albums in a bubble envelope with 2-3 layers inside as well, however one of the two albums arrived with several dents, technically in every borders, due surely to the fact that the album was not well enough packed and this album is more fragile due to its big size and weaker album packaging and design. Prices are a bit higher than Mwave, and you'd need to purchase more to get free shipping. I would only purchase there if the products are sold out on mwave.
Kpoptown
Ktown4u



Half/half (sells genuine and non-genuine)

A little more explanation about this one, there are several sellers that I knew about, some which I have placed on the legit seller list in the past (and in fact received comments saying that they were doubting about the legitimacy of certain albums, and I completely agreed!) , some which I never mentioned, and that is because these sellers do sell a good chunk of legit signed albums, however two/three albums end up not being genuine, especially I tend to see that is the case for SM signed albums (such as SNSD albums signed in some silver/gold pen by just one member with a C1 komca sticker... something is just not right). So I believe for this list of sellers, you'd have to be on the watch out? They are not as "legit" as the first category of legit sellers. I'd say for less popular groups you'd have less risk to fall on a non legit signed album whilst SM signed albums would be more likely to not be legit. Just be extra sure to analyze well the albums before purchasing one.

EBAY SELLERS

Kpopmarket01
Kpop_music2
Kpopshop789
Penguinrecord
smusic_ente0 
The_king_of_carrot_flowers



NON-TRUSTWORTHY (sells fake)


EBAY SELLERS

ahamoon007
Bw10463407
Gkvcho8
Jintacho
Jswpanda
jhwangmi (sells fake signed photos)
Kan-Hanh
Lejinyoun_0
M2ybox
Pandoramusic
Taesicho_0
Uniqueurlife

WEBSITE PLATFORMS

Aliexpress
Kpopmart
Popthatcase

CAROUSELL

ksigns


Feel free to comment asking whether a seller is a seller that is NOT listed here is selling genuine or non-genuine signed albums, I will take a look at what he is selling and will add him on the list according to which category he is.  HOWEVER, I would prefer not to add Facebook sellers, or some sellers that sell on a smaller scale as those people may not be the most experienced and may have bought genuine and non genuine signed albums without knowing and reselling. I do not wish to label them as non-trustworthy.

List last updated 9.10.18 9th of October 2018


Show Comments:

209 comments:

  1. OMG my heart is finally at ease knowing kpoptown is legit! I pre-ordered a signed BTS CD months ago and (despite having my dad examine it with a magnifying glass haha) have always been paranoid no matter how legit it looked. xD

    I was about to buy an autographed album off grapemusiccd, so I'm glad to see they have your stamp of approval too haha. Thanks for making these posts! I finally feel at ease~ ^u^

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yaaaay! Glad I was able to help \(^_^)/ hahaha I can understand that feeling of unsureness, that's why I never buy unless I have done enough research!

      Delete
  2. Hi! I would like to ask if the signed albums from Kpop unlimited is legit? The albums looked pretty legit to me and I'm not sure if I am confident that it's legit! (><)

    Is it possible to contact my email and I can send you the photo?

    My email is virgopalz@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Never heard of Kpop unlimited :/ I'd need a link to see that! And if you want to contact me via email you can find it here : http://cafarnaumbox.blogspot.com/p/contact.html , please send me an email :)

      Delete
  3. Hi :) thank you so much for this! i would like to ask, do you think jane678s is a trusted ebay seller that sells genuine signed albums?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, just checked his eBay and I don't see any listings of ended listings with signed albums, mind sending me of a link of one of his signed albums' listing? I can only see him selling fan made goods....

      Delete
    2. Hi, ah i'm so sorry!! I got so busy and forgot about this. :/
      I just checked too and yeah the listings are gone from that seller. I bought an EXO signed album from that seller in 2014 believing it was real, however.. now i'm not so sure if it's actually genuine. I have sent an email to Cafarnaumbox@hotmail.com. Do you think you could check the photos out to see if it's legit?

      Delete
  4. Hello again haha! I know people use kpopmarket01 on ebay for photocards, but I was wondering if their autographed albums were real. The amount of SM artists raised some alarms, but so many people trust them I'm not sure haha. Thank you for your help! You're really stopping a lot of people from being scammed out of their hard earned money! \^u^/

    Here's some of their listings:
    - http://www.ebay.com/itm/SHINee-SHINee-World-Ver-Vol-1-ALL-MEMBERs-AUTOGRAPHED-/231838499559?hash=item35faa6c2e7
    -http://www.ebay.com/itm/f-x-NU-ABO-1st-Mini-Album-CD-Photo-Booklet-AUTOGRAPHED-CD-K-POP-/231838471752?hash=item35faa65648
    -http://www.ebay.com/itm/CNBLUE-2gether-Vol-2-B-ver-CD-68p-Booklet-KANG-MIN-HYUK-AUTOGRAPHED-CD-/321952117483?hash=item4af5d772eb

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, I actually just noticed that the green shinee album they listed has the member names in the wrong spots. I didn't even notice the first time around. :O

      They just put up this listing though: http://www.ebay.com/itm/SHINee-SHINee-World-Ver-B-Vol-1-ALL-MEMBERs-AUTOGRAPHED-/231817573601?hash=item35f96774e1

      Delete
    2. Hi! Most of the signed albums they sold are pretty legit to me, apart from that green Shinee album, the signs don't correspond to the members, I am not very familiar with SHINee signatures, but their signs look a bit off.... Plus it's a c1 sticker..... So odd.... While the other one, the b version is legit though.mas for the fx, hmmmm. I haven't done enough research, I've seen another copy like that very similar, I'd need to do more research to pinpoint whether it is legit or not. So.... I think this seller clearly doesn't know they are selling a fake signed album, as most of theirs are legit (like the CN blue is legit to me) apart from that Shinee green album :/

      Delete
  5. hi there! i sent you an email, so i hope you receive it soon! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi! You're the person who sent the email about the matrix and seventeen signed albums right? If so I have answered you :)

      Delete
  6. Anyone know about seller m2ybox?? I want to buy a photocard set of TWICE but they're selling it for really cheap so I'm suspecting if they're fake sellers or not.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, erm if you are asking about signed items, you know really can't do nothing if you can't read what I write in my articles .___. I listed him as a fake seller for signed items, and as for his photo set all are unofficial, please read thoroughly his eBay listings, you got the answer there, it says unofficial http://m.imgur.com/Ih93VRA

      Delete
  7. Hey! I do have a question regarding YesAsia!
    I've ordered the BLOCK B Photobook SIGNED a while ago, and now it finally came but I'm a bit 'worried'? I've checked the signs and they look a bit different. Some of them look alike and some look a bit off. But on the other hand while googling the autographs sometimes they looked different from other official autographs if you know what I mean.
    Do you think YesAsia could possibly provide also fakes or do you think it's normal?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi! Do you mean that when you compared on signatures you googled they looked different? If that's the case yes totally normally, it is highly unlikely they will sign it exactly like their official signature, they will use a more simplified signature because there is so much to sign. I highly doubt yesasia would sell fake signed stuff, I never had any issues with them so far, I would try if I were you to perhaps search for anyone who has a mwave one and compare them if you're really unsure, since both yesasia and mwave sold it, and mwave is for sure legit since they are mnet broadcasting company :3

      Delete
  8. Hello! I've been using your advice to avoid fake sellers on ebay. What do you think of the seller penguinrecords from ebay?
    http://stores.ebay.com/penguinrecord/Autographed-/_i.html?_fsub=12984788010

    I wanted to buy the Mamacita album for a friend. It has a promo sticker, but the white ink reminded me of fake signatures. It's not just on this album, but a few others have white/gold ink and that's usually a sign of a fake?
    Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi! I have analyzed several of his signed albums and they are legit! So I think so far this seller could be added to the trustworthy sellers, I remember checking him out ages ago but forgot about his eBay name hahah. White ink doesn't mean it is fake, it is usually used when an album is dark, so that there is a contrast between the album and the sign (but not always the case though). And the gold pen is also used sometimes, but not as much, the fact is if you see a photo signed with a gold marker it means it is fake in that case, but as for albums, you'd have to compare with all the others they signed whether it was the same pen color.

      Delete
  9. I would like to ask if this seller is approved: http://www.ebay.com/usr/hallyu_wave?_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2754. Thank You!~

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello, I cannot classify him in this listing because he is not a "professional" seller, but I have seen so far on his current listing 3 things: the astro and 24k are genuine since they come from mwave, but the Chen signed picture is not genuine. I think he purchased things and is reselling them without knowing whether it's genuine.

      Delete
  10. are you familiar with ktown4u and if they are trustworthy for signed albums? it has a preorder for signed got7's upcoming album that are kind of cheap so i wasn't sure about it.
    thank you :3

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello~ I believe ktown4u should be selling legit signed ones, it seems like they could be ordering those from mwave (just like how kpoptown does), since those are one member signed albums, it's not likely that they would scam people because scammers tend to sell all member signed and got7 is one of those groups where signed albums are the easiest to get! I am waiting for more people on the net doing Unboxing of their signed items before really being 100% sure!

      Delete
    2. thank you so much!! i appreciate your feedback~

      Delete
  11. Bw10463407 is not trustworthy?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi, can you tell me if this person is legitimate? http://www.ebay.com/usr/heavymetalatef?_trksid=p2047675.l2559

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello~ the person resells things they bought off mwave so yep so far everything they sell signed is legit ^^b

      Delete
  13. kpopmart is legit though sometimes the signatures do not look real, but for some groups it does. i think they said on their tumblr page that they would take serious measures against those spreading that they are selling fake signatures. if you think about it, they won't sell fakes. they are a established company and once people know they sell fakes, it would ruin their reputation. you can ask about their authenticity of their signatures at their tumblr page.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello, kpopmart DID sell some genuine signed copies in the past, but nowadays they don't anymore. I have went through all their pages and none are genuine. They are actually taking the opportunity of their good reputation to sell non genuine copies, and since everyone trusts them, nobody would doubt them. There will always be people purchasing from them, and even if people spread that they don't sell genuine, they will still be able to sell because newbies won't know. And they state that they receive their albums from the management company. There are only TWO ways to achieve signed albums, either from mwave (but sites such as yesasia, ktown4u , or kpoptown bought from mwave and sell on their platform) (mwave is very trustworthy because they are the m countdown broadcast channel) and from broadcast companies (those copies are ONLY promo albums) (those copies may be resold on eBay by people who purchased them from broadcast companies or have links with them and get them for free). Kpopmart only sells C1 albums and not PROMO albums, and they sell albums that not even mwave can get (such as EXO, because mwave is very strict And wants absolutely the artists themselves to sign) (mwave albums are always C1). I have compares the copies, and if you check my other articles you will see in some examples KpopMart, and none are genuine. Please provide SOLID proof and not just "oh they have a reputation" if you believe they are legit. Such as comparison of album signatures with legit ones (eg picture of a PDnim posted in Instagram)

      Delete
  14. Hi:) do you mind to see if bts itmfl signed album from this shop (popthatcase.com) is real? Thanks :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello! I have checked the website and it showed me 3 signed BTS products. However, 2 of the products are not genuine, but one of them is. BUT, I think the genuine image one is a stolen image, so at the end you won't receive the product they've put. So I believe it isn't trustworthy :/

      Delete
  15. Hey Lassy, how do you feel about kshop4u as a seller for signed albums? I've heard that they're a trustworthy seller but lately some of the albums (well, at least the bts ones since I'm mainly looking at those) they have put up for sale have a signature or two that look kinda off? Thanks so much for your help!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi! Omg I completely forgot to add them into my list O___O they are totally trustworthy for signed stuff! Ever since I know them I have been checking them out regularly and everything is genuine! :) signatures may look a bit weird hahaa but I think he often gets his hands on signed albums during the end of their promotion? So the members get more tired and sign sometimes oddly their signatures, but overall you can still see it's genuine ^~^ added him in the list!

      Delete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi! It is legit! If I hadn't bought a copy before I would have totally bought this one as the price is really good (cheaper since it's not a promo album but who cares? As long as signatures are genuine), and the signatures are not as simplified as usual, so they look much nicer! Rapmon added RM and Jimin has added BTS as I am guessing they weren't as much in a rush? (And weren't too lazy?) It happens ^^ anyway I would remove him from the legit list if ever I were to spot even ONE non genuine signed album, I regularly check out the people listed on my list!!

      Delete
  17. Hi I hope you dont mind me posting a comment here
    just had a question about
    http://i1220.photobucket.com/albums/dd454/faith_genesis_raven/s-l1600_zpsvswowy25.jpg
    thats just one image but other which was on the sellers post had not for sale on the barcode and the sticker

    I have been offered a promo cd of her latest album why to buy

    Although I do not know if I am being a bit paranoid because it is decent money or just that the signature was slightly off maybe but then it is a promo album which made me confused.

    I just wanted a second opinion if possibile

    I am a big fan of Taeyeon and was excited about the prospect of getting something signed of hers but I dont want to waste money aswell.

    Thanks very much
    Kind Regards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi:)
      it looks genuine signed to me.. im interested in that too! Can you share with me where you going to buy it from?

      Delete
    2. I know this is a little bit late, and that you probably already purchased the CD, but I'm pretty sure that I can say that the autographed cd that you purchased is unfortunately a fake. I was almost about ready to purchase an I signed promo album from that seller, but handdollmaking told me that the signed cds that they were selling for Taeyeon were fakes.

      If you compare the Why promo albums that handollmaking is selling http://www.ebay.com/itm/TAEYEON-SNSD-Why-2nd-Mini-Promo-with-Autographed-Signed-/182207773348?var=&hash=item2a6c6dfaa4:m:mi9wo_tg6qv0yyircjwSxKg here to these ones you can see that the gap between the bottom part of the butterfly is a lot smaller on his. In addition, the butterfly itself looks to be very sloppy.

      Delete
  18. Omg thank you so much for putting this list together! <3

    ReplyDelete
  19. Hello, thank you so much for this list it really helped!
    I was wondering if this seller http://m.ebay.com.au/sch/i.html?isRefine=true&_pgn=8&_nkw=seller%3Atridera&_sasl=tridera was trustworthy?
    Thanks :)

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hi, thanks for posting this ^^ It helps a lot!
    ANYWAYS, I found a seller on eBay that sells Astro's Summer Vibes with all members' signatures AND the set of Eunwoo photocards that I so desperately want! I don't want to be fooled again (wasted my money on two fake photo cards just recently, I don't want to waste any more money on fake stuff) and since I have no eye for this kind of things, I was wondering if you could take a look and tell me what you think?

    http://www.ebay.com/itm/152235250979?var=451425751728

    ReplyDelete
  21. Is thejellyhouse legitimate? I was looking at this listing: http://m.ebay.com.au/itm/OFFICIAL-B-A-P-BAP-MATRIX-SIGNED-ALBUM-CHOICE-OF-PHOTOCARD-Zelo-Bang-/162202218581?nav=SEARCH&varId=461176885198

    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  22. Hi.
    I was wondering if pandoramusic on ebay is a trustworthy seller.
    It would help a lot if you could help me.
    Thank you so much for this :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello, I believe his signed CDs/albums are not genuine. I will add him into the list!

      Delete
  23. Hi I was just wondering if these are real? I really want to buy them but hesitant. Thank you. Its from kpopshop789:
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/122216790338

    ReplyDelete
  24. I would like to ask if KPOP Gate is trustworthy.
    I just found VIXX's autographed CD

    http://kpopgate.com/Product/Detail/view/pid/6033/cid/36/spn/VIXX-Kratos-3rd-Mini-Album-REAL-SIGNED-AUTOGRAPHED-PROMO-CD-LEO-PHOTOCARD

    which is exactly the same as the one on ebay's grapemusiccd:

    http://www.ebay.com/itm/VIXX-Kratos-3rd-Mini-Album-REAL-SIGNED-AUTOGRAPHED-PROMO-CD-LEO-PHOTOCARD-/162322280471?hash=item25cb297017:g:~uIAAOSwEzxYUulk

    Do you think KPOP Gate is trustworthy? Or even both KPOP Gate and grapemusiccd are the same seller? Or unfortunately the website is fake?

    Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, kpopgate is grapemusiccd's friend, so I believe he would be genuine. I guess they share what they sell. ^^

      Delete
  25. Can "limited_logos_mania" from eBay be trusted?

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hello,

    May I know if this shop sells real autographed bts albums?
    https://sg.carousell.com/carpe.diem/

    Thank you for your time :)

    ReplyDelete
  27. Hello is the store Kpoppin USA legit?It doesn't sell anything signed and the albums I've purchased DO have their Komca stickers AND their genie music codes/promotions (on SM albums).So from my point of view I believe it is legit but I want a second opinion

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, i don't know, I don't know every stores, this list is just for signed items, can't help you out. Should be legit the album you got, it's rare to find fake albums in general as long as you don't buy from a chinese seller.

      Delete
  28. Hi! Is this carousell user selling authentic signed albums? http://carousell.com/jkingdom.oppa/Page

    ReplyDelete
  29. Even though you listed The_king_of_carrot_flowers as a trustworthy seller, I want to buy this SNSD autograph but it was signed with a blue pen and as you said in one of your other articles idols mostly sign with a black pen. So should I buy the autograph? Here is the listing
    http://www.ebay.com/itm/Girls-Generation-Mini-Album-Gee-Autographed-Signed-Sunny-CD-SNSD-Photobook-/172392240780?hash=item282360d68c:g:u0EAAOSwal5YFfPE

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, yes that album does look fishy! I don't really know well snsd members signatures, but that signature just looks... weird. I have never see any signatures with such blue pen and thick. It doesn't look very pro, as if a kid signed himself. But yes, although that seller is considered majority of times legit signed album seller, that one album isn't (but i my be wrong, but my guts think this not genuine!)

      Delete
  30. Is kpopmarket01 trustworthy? I am asking this since I don't know if this autograph is real or fake and as you said in one of your previous replies to someone, you said that you don't know if he is trustworthy or not. Here is the listing http://www.ebay.com/itm/SNSD-GIRLS-GENERATION-Oh-Vol-2-CD-PhotoBooklet-SOOYOUNGs-AUTOGRAPHED-CD-/321939000956?hash=item4af50f4e7c:g:qN8AAOSweW5U3FcK

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hi, I was wondering if yullybang on eBay was trustworthy. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, please read this http://cafarnaumbox.blogspot.com.es/2016/08/signed-kpop-photocards-photos-often.html

      Delete
  32. Hi! I was wondering if jswpanda on eBay was trustworthy! Thank you so much and here is a link to the album I am considering :)

    http://m.ebay.com/itm/182393309543?NAV=HOME

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, did you even bother reading the list or using ctrl+f ??

      Delete
  33. Hi, I was wondering if bartacus13 is trustworthy on eBay. It would appreciate if you could help. Thank you so much!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can't speak for the photocards but among the CD's I've seen the autographs appear to be genuine. I checked his purchases and some are from genuine sellers listed on this blog, and they all gave him positive ratings. While I'm not 100% certain, at this time I don't see a reason to suspect this seller as a fake.

      Delete
  34. Do you know if luxurygoods-kpop is a legit seller or not? They had been selling signed albums of BTS lately and their signed albums seem to be genuine but I want to make sure since some of the albums do have the silver sticker with the korean words but don't have the not for sale/promotion only stickers. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When I was doing my own research I was wondering this too and when I asked about where they got a specific album they said it was a promo album but the album had a C1 sticker instead of the not for sale Korean one that it should have for promos. It could just be that one that didn't match up but I would ask them just to be safe!

      Delete
  35. Hello! Thank you for this! I know for the half/half sellers you mentioned that DM artists would be more likely to be fake from these sellers. I'm am thinking of getting a BTS signed album from the_king_of_carrot_flowers and I know you had him listed as half/half. Would you mind taking a look for me? Thank you so much!

    http://m.ebay.com/itm/BTS-3rd-Mini-Album-The-Most-Beautiful-Moment-in-Life-Autographed-Signed-Promo-CD-/332161058547?nav=WATCHING_ACTIVE

    ReplyDelete
  36. Hello!! I'm pretty sure this hasn't been asked yet but is this Instagram seller legit? They have a decently big following and some of the albums look legit but some don't, like maybe nct's sigs... I'm not 100% though. They have some bts albums on there too

    https://www.instagram.com/promoautographs/

    ReplyDelete
  37. Hello i was wondering if noblekorea is okay? He has a listing for a kara album i want that is signed. Please respond!

    ReplyDelete
  38. Hello i was wondering if noblekorea is okay? He has a listing for a kara album i want that is signed. Please respond! Here's the listing.
    http://m.ebay.com/itm/KARA-7th-Mini-Album-In-Love-AUTOGRAPHED-SIGNED-PROMO-CD-K-Pop-Excellent-Cond-/201914974289?nav=SEARCH

    ReplyDelete
  39. I was wondering if ktown4u was okay. I bought a signed twice album like 4 months ago but I would feel kind of silly if it wasn't authentic

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ehhhh I was sure I added him into the list before! I guess I must have deleted by mistake.... anyway legit, they get their signed albums/merch from mwave.

      Delete
  40. Oh gosh I'm so glad to see TheJellyHouse on the list of authentic sellers. Because they are the only person I can find that is selling this signed album with a rare limited photocard that I really wanted. Thank you! :)

    ReplyDelete
  41. Very useful, thank you for posting. What about www.kpopocean.com ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, this article is about sites selling SIGNED stuff, as far as I know kpopocean doesn't sell anything signed, so it doesn't concern this article.

      Delete
  42. Any chance you can check and see if this person is legit?
    http://www.ebay.com/usr/jedimonk?_trksid=p2047675.l2559

    ReplyDelete
  43. Please help me! It's super important. I spent $90 on an autographed Miss A album from Kpopshop789 and I'm so scared that it's fake. They said it's from Mwave and I want to have some faith but I'm just so worried! please look at it if you can and tell me what you think. Thank you.

    http://www.ebay.com/itm/122445026157

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, sorry I misplaced that seller, he is in the category 50/50 legit/nonlegit, that album seems genuine, but that seller looooves to make a lot of fake signed stuff for popular groups, so I don't think you'd have to fret for less popular groups

      Delete
  44. Any chance you can check out this person? They sell quite a lot and says their albums are promo albums but I want to make sure. Especially with their Lovelyz signed albums. Thank you. http://www.ebay.com/usr/bartacus013?_trksid=p2055119.m1438.l2754

    ReplyDelete
  45. Hi! I found your blog and I saw you said that bw10463407 sells fake signed albums. I'm really frustrated because I bought two albums with him/her. How did you know that it's fake?

    ReplyDelete
  46. Hi there! There's a relatively new ebay seller, hallyusuperstore, that's selling a bunch of promo albums. The signatures seem legit, but it'd be nice to have another pair of eyes look at them. Thanks so much!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hallyu Super store is Quietrio, who is on the above list. He just recently changed his id.

      Delete
  47. Do artists have simplified signatures for just general staff and different ones for PD nims? I noticed SNSD's signatures for Holiday Night are drastically different when they add a comment to someone and on top of that, they sign somewhere else on the album.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Hey just look for some help to determine if this items signatures are authentic or not. If you could please take a look Lassy or anyone else and tell me what you think thanks. Here's the link http://www.ebay.com/itm/152568214244

    ReplyDelete
  49. Hi! There's a seller called ahamoon star shop on Shopee, different country versions too (I've seen for my, ph, tw, sg versions of the online store). I actually nearly purchased something from there but I stopped myself because I had doubts (https://shopee.ph/ahamoon.ph/795241984). But I'm glad to have found an expert who can help out! They have other artist signatures too like Twice and Black Pink. It'd be such a shame if their stuff weren't authentic.:(

    ReplyDelete
  50. Even trusted ebay sellers like Mojasajo, Handdollmaking, or Hallyusuperstore have some fake signed albums since sometimes official signed promo albums are done by managers especially when it comes to SM entertainment. But that guy is totally fake. Avoid him at all costs.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Hey there, I was curious do you know if harampapa is a legit seller they have a ton of stuff and my friends and i have been interested in buying stuff from him. But we cant find anything only about him. Do you know if he is legit he is on ebay.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Hey, can you tell me if dreampedal96 and hwan-chank on eBay sell real products? Thankykj

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They are both legit sellers and actually they are selling non-signed products. So kinda irrelevant with this board.

      Delete
    2. What about "kpop_music2"? It's a legit seller? Or the autographs in the album are fake?

      Delete
  53. Hi there, I’m wondering if autograph from smusic_ente0 look legit?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not sure some autographs seems to be a bit off in my opinion I would be cautious and probably avoid

      Delete
    2. All of his albums seem fine except BTS. His/her BTS albums are terribly off.

      Delete
    3. Actually I have one more questions, what do you guys think regarding his exo autographs? And also do you mind also check kpop_music2? They have similar styles, and it seems that both of them sell PROMO albums

      Delete
    4. https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.ca%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F253573116289
      The four exact autographs here
      And also https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.ca%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F292526026800 this is the autographed poster from the second store

      Delete
    5. Some signatures look fake considering patterns and strokes but it's not thier fault. SM managers are always good at doing signatures for their busy idols. If I were you, I would avoid all SM signed albums

      Delete
  54. Hello! Can you tell me if Tridera signed cds are legit or fake? Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah she buys them from mwave.
      sometimes even includes the random picked photocard which adds to it being legit.
      I bought a twice album from her didnt have any problems what so ever.

      Delete
  55. Hi!! A friend of mine bought a signed album by BTS V but i think it's fake ;_; do you know how to recognize his signature or someone who can help me with it?

    ReplyDelete
  56. Hi. Can you tell me if h-us115`s signed albums are legit?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, he is not a professional seller, just a casual seller, so I do not "evaluate" the degree of trustworthiness in this case.

      Delete
  57. I found this (https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/bPwAAOSw5IFa-oka/s-l1600.jpg) which seems fake but I'm not sure to be honest. It's from an eBay seller with less than 50 feedback ratings and the price (though it's an auction) seems to good to be true. It also does look fairly fake based on how similar the pen pressure on each signature looks. Or... is that just me?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, that's 100% legit album. People are too picky about pen pressure and looks. But that's too consistent to be fake. you don't have to worry about that album at all. If you want to see the real fake BTS albums check m2ybox, kpopshop789, jswpanda, and Bw10463407. You will see how terrible fake BTS signed albums are.

      Delete
  58. Hello, one of the authentic ebay sellers you listed has a Young Forever album but it only has 6 out of the 7 members signatures. It's missing Jins. Does this mean that it's fake? Should this seller be avoided after all or put in the 50/50? Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, can you tell me which one and possibly which listing (link)? I haven't double checked them in a while

      Delete
  59. Kpop_music2 is selling signed albums on auction on eBay but I'm in doubt whether they're fake or not, mainly due to their low prices (then again, since they're auctions, the prices usually rise but still...).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ihttps://www.ebay.com/itm/BTS-YOU-NEVER-WALK-ALONE-Autograph-ALL-MEMBER-Signed-PROMO-ALBUM-KPOP-signature/292492434732?hash=item4419e85d2c:g:W6wAAOSwS6ZauCBM

      I have doubt on this album but other than that, all other his albums seem fine

      Delete
    2. I wanted to buy a signed album from this seller too, but I don't know if the signatures are fake, can u help me?

      Delete
    3. Hi,
      I hope you havent bought the BTS album yet, because i think that its a fake! the album has the promo komca sticker, but its missing the NOT FOR SALE printed on it and instead has the numbered barcode for regular albums (i think that regular komca sticker was removed and the seller has attached the promo komca sticker to this album themselves)
      The signatures themselves look a little spread out and sloppy.

      I have noticed that this seller sells a mix of real and fake signatures (fakes particularly for BTS, EXO and Wanna One)
      they turn many regular albums into fake "promos"

      Delete
  60. I'm very much in doubt when it comes to signed SM albums and try to stay away from them, at least if they're non-promo. So I did find these signed SHINee albums I'm interested in (https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/nDgAAOSwBXhbCP8T/s-l1600.jpg and https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/FpMAAOSwxURbRBM~/s-l1600.jpg) but as they're not 비매 albums I honestly don't even know if they're legit or not. I'd say they look much better compared to the obviously fake ones from China. The seller is from Korea and I asked them about the albums to which they replied that the previous owner got them signed at a fansign. Aren't albums usually signed on each member's individual page though?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Both albums look legit to me even though they are not "비매" albums. Patterns and strokes look consistent and they are all identical to their early period. (They don't change their signs much though) I can confidently say they are legit. But always be careful when you buy Non-promo albums

      Delete
  61. https://shopee.ph/ahamoon.ph is this seller legit because I’m very hesitant about this thing because it’s my first time buying a signed album, I don’t know how to look at fake autographs it’s too confusing, please answer my question thank you so much.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My message disappeared before it was posted so here's a brief summary:

      - I do not recommend them at all.
      - They sell signed posters and postcards just like Chinese sellers which is usually a bad sign... unless it was signed at a special event (which is not the case for what I have seen on the seller's page).
      - Looks like the signatures were done by the same person, with no focus on where to put the different signs on the album.
      - The signatures are too "clean" - almost reminds me of photocards with printed signatures on them.

      I highly recommend you to only go for Korean sellers with a high rating (like the trustworthy ones stated above). To avoid getting scammed, always go for albums with a 비매 sticker - but the album should also have "NOT FOR SALE" written on the back, as some sellers put on the 비매 stickers on regular albums to scam people. The "NOT FOR SALE" barcode can not be replaced that easily though. Oh, and there's Mwave's Meet & Greet as well (and Kpoptown - as well as Yesasia - sells signed albums every now and then).

      Delete
  62. Hi, can anyone help me? I'm looking at this album & wondering if the signature are legit? Actually i have been looking for this album for quite some time
    https://www.ebay.com.sg/itm/SuperJunior-HeeChul-Autograph-ALL-MEMBER-Signed-PROMO-ALBUM-KPOP-signature/292495423116?hash=item441a15f68c:g:ySwAAOSwqVdatN-U#viTabs_0

    ReplyDelete
  63. Hello,

    Can someone tell me if the seller smusic_ente0 on ebay is legit? I want to buy this album :
    - https://www.ebay.fr/itm/2NE1-CRUSH-Autograph-ALL-MEMBER-Signed-PROMO-ALBUM-KPOP-signature/253823104139?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649#viTabs_0

    But I am not sure it's legit.

    Thank you !!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello,

      Thank you for your response !!! I wasn't sure because it is a new seller and it is very similar to another new account called kpop_music2. The 2 was createdin febuary maybe just a coincidence, I suppose they are both legit. Did you bought from him?

      Thank you again !!!

      Delete
  64. That 2ne1 signed album is undoubtedly legit. Their signatures are kinda sophisticated. So, I can tell whether it is legit or not by just glance. If someone can copy like that, he/she must have a Nobel prize for copying signatures. For those two sellers (Kpop_.. and smusic_.. ), I have to be very careful evaluating them. When they first came out, some of their BTS, Wanna one and Exo signed albums were really doubtful. Especially some of their BTS albums were so horrible that anyone could tell that those were fake like some people already stated above. I don’t know it was their intention or they were just scammed from some vendors. However, they are moving toward to legit sellers’ category. I guess they don’t have any problem with the authenticity of their albums right now. Just my thought.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Omg, I have to revoke my above opinion. I just browsed trohrough their ebay pages and they are still selling some fake bts and red velvet album. I don't know why they are doing this with 95% of other legit signed albums. Just can't understand. May be they don't know how to tell the difference because they are new in the industry?

      Delete
  65. https://www.ebay.com/itm/BTS-SALE-This-WEEK-ONLY-25-Autograph-Signed-ALL-MEMBER-PROMO-ALBUM-KPOP/253823081986?hash=item3b1908de02:m:moH1Hb4wDfE1mYOIO6btetQ

    Still selling these kinds of fakes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello, thank you for all your help !! I think the 2NE1 signature are real too but I have some trouble to recognize CL autograph as it is always so different. But apparently you know a lot about signature, can I ask you if this one is legit https://www.instagram.com/p/BmOZO-gl-a9/?utm_source=ig_share_sheet&igshid=389f0ws3u1m5 ? I found Minzy's autograph strange compared to her others signature. Hope they are really selling some legit stuff, there is too many fake those day that's so sad... I inform you that that kpop and emusic is the same seller !! Anyway thank you so much for your help I hope you are right and that it is on of their legit album !! Really appreciate your help !!! Have a good day !!!

      Delete
  66. Even if signatures looks fake and the way minzy write her name is different, I think the signature is 80~90% legit since all they follow all the patterns when 2ne1 members draw signatures (following all the drawing patterns is really hard even for very skilled forgers) . I guess when they sign this album they were in a rush or they were signed the album with uncomfortable position (standing without chair and tables and signing against the wall). However, I would not buy the album since the CL and Minzy's signatures are so sloppy and there is only little value with that messy signatures. So, my advice is don't buy it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your quick response, unfortunatly I already bought it T_T I hope it is a real one !!!

      Delete
  67. Please don't buy from Kpop_music2. Here's why. If you look at Twice signed album by mojasajo and hallyusuperstore. Their position, pattern and pen depth is almost identical. Mojasajo ( https://www.ebay.com/itm/153120923674 ) Hallyusuperstore( https://www.ebay.com/itm/153128261899 ) But Kpop_music2 has so differnt Twice autographed albums and you can easily tell they are fakes.

    Here are examples.

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/292716043977

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/292716042598

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/292716041796

    Also, these fake promo signed albums even have photocards. I have been watching Mojasajo, Hallysuperstore, and Handollmaking selling Twice "Summer night" signed promo albums and non of them have photocards on their Twice summer night promo albums.

    One funny thing is that he is also selling legit twice "summer night" signed album. https://www.ebay.com/itm/292665486922 (I don't know why he add photocards on this album, but signatures in itself is legit)

    So, if you aren't familiar with signatures, don't buy from him. 80~90% of his signed albums are legit but about 10~20% of his album end up being fake. So, be careful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello,

      I confirm Kpop_music2 is selling fake item, not only the signature are fake the album himself is not legit. I unfortunatly bought the promo CD CRUSH 2NE1 from is 2nd account smusic_ente0. For a promo CD release in febuary 2014 there is a case printed 2014 (no problem) with a CD printed in 2015 (impossible as the promo CD are printed before the release date) in fact the matrix/runout correspond to the 2nd press....very very strange that another CD come in a case of a Promo CD. No refund possible for me he don't negociate anything. I highly recommend to avoid this seller even if it looks legit it is definitly not 100% sure that it is authentic.

      Hope it help !!

      Delete
    2. Hi, thanks you for your comment, I have added him into the half legit category.

      Delete
  68. No that 2NE1 is not fake, the singatures themselves are 100% legit. When idols run out of their promo albums, they sometimes bring their non-promo(C1) albums with signatures and distribute to bradcasting staffs. However, that's another problem of that seller. He frequently turns non-promo album in to promo. I sometimes see him changing his non-promo albums into promo by attaching "비매" stickers on them. The best way is avoid him.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. no the CD is from 2015 sonot 100% authentic, maybe the other part is but it is definitly not 100% authentic.

      Delete
  69. For the disparity of the album and case, I guess he might got a broken CD or just a album without CD. Then, he bought another album online(since non signed old album is very cheap around 10 dollars.) and replcase it. So, you might not worry that much. Still avoid him since his BTS, Wanna One, EXO, Red Velvet and Lovelyz albums are very fishy.

    ReplyDelete
  70. I was wondering if this SNSD genie autograph album is real or fake? Seller is merrygorec Link: https://www.ebay.com/itm/SNSD-Girls-Generation-Genie-2nd-mini-kor-Album-autographed-all-members/232864626313?hash=item3637d03689:g:CB8AAOSw-CpX-6l5

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This one is definitely a fake and the other SNSD album (run devil run) is also fake.

      Delete
  71. Hi, my concern is about Kpop eBay seller jhwangmi. 6 months I ordered a signed bo young picture and had it put in a psa jsa case and it came back as non authentic. I then printed out screen shots of random items of the 1300+ that he has posted and none match the original signatures, most look like the same person has signed them all. Seller claims to have an infinite source and 'special source in Korea' I have seen with this seller multiple posts being sold and a replacement post put up of the same item immediately after sale. Help take these people selling fake Kpop merchandise down and prosecuted as it is unfair to the music groups and to victims that buy them for these Vultures to make hundreds of thousands of dollars for their scam items. thank you. Ebay search: kpop signed

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That guy is 100% fake even the signatures on Ebay postings also fake no matter he replace it when shipping or not. I just don't understand why Ebay don't take any action against those fake sellers like him.

      Delete
    2. Hi, yes indeed all the signed photos he sells are fake... I have added him onto the list although he isn't selling albums, but there are so many sellers like him... The list won't end. Because Kpop artists don't sign any photos in general. So I'd classify 99% of signed photos as fake on ebay.

      Delete
    3. I am 13 I bought a few items from this seller he suckered me into giving him positive feedback and I matched the signatures to the real ones and they were fake I filed a police report and notify the eBay and was told by both places I had to file online with the FBI on the ic3 website and if I wanted to sue him I would have to do so in his jurisdiction and I could get my money back along with all of my court cost I have his name and address and was able to do a search on his name at the court with my mom's help because she would have to file the lawsuit I'm not of age but we found out through court records that he was just sued for stolen merchandise we live over 250 miles away and it would cost more for us to file a lawsuit I was given the suggestion to spend some more money with him and give him negative feedback on his eBay account and let everybody know what he was doing because I was suckered into giving him multiple positive feedbacks and then later found out what I was sold was fake

      Delete
  72. beware of kpop_music2 and smusic_ente0 . They keep making fake signed albums.

    Their got7 albums have so much different positions comparing other two sellers and Yugyeom's signatures are so horrible that anyone can tell they are fakes.

    Just compare them, then you can easily tell them.

    Kpop_music2's got7 signatures:

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/253937530622

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/292775224989


    other two legit sellers' got7 signatures:

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/173590974105

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/153185479967


    Also, their BTS signed albums are fake af.

    ReplyDelete
  73. Hi, I've read all your articles on the signed albums and they've all been really helpful, thank you! I wanted to buy a signed BTS album and I found this one for HYYH Pt1 ( https://m.bonanzamarket.co.uk/listings/BTS-OFFICIAL-in-the-mood-for-LOVE-PT1-signed-7-members-signature-album-KPOP/651937703 ) and this one for Young Forever ( https://m.bonanzamarket.co.uk/listings/BTS-OFFICIAL-Young-Forever-signed-7-members-signature-album-KPOP-Korea/649169461 ) They are also selling other albums. I couldn't tell if it looked legitimate or not so I wanted a 2nd opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  74. Hello, I am debating if I should buy the promo albums of GOT7. Can you confirm if these are legit..?
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/GOT7-PRESENT-YOU-VOL-3-Autographed-Signed-Promo-Album-updated-11-11/153256218625?var=453127902170

    also this GOT7 group signed album
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/Got7-Signed-Turbulence-Album/263943777681

    I don't know how familiar you are with GOT7 but, someone won a group signed album for free this year at KCON so I am debating if I should buy the promo album right now or if I should wait until KCON 2019 and see if anyone will win the group signed and end up not wanting one. Can you give me an insight on this? Thank you so much ^^

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Both albums are absolutely legit but signatures are not that nicely done and look a little sloppy. If I were you, I would wait until KCON since KCON signatures are generally more sincerely done than promo signed albums done in a rush.

      Delete
  75. Hello! I hope you are still able to look at pictures to see if they are real or fake, I really want to buy this signed album, at least find a legit signed version of this one. Can you tell me if this one is legit or not, I don't want to spend so much money on something that isn't legit, thank you so much for providing this information to us :)

    https://lunarcatco.com/collections/signed-albums-photos/products/bts-young-forever-pt-2-blue-version-autographed-album

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 100% fake and this seller's all signed albums are nothing but some fakes.

      Delete
    2. https://www.ebay.com/itm/253991527784

      https://www.ebay.com/itm/323539374651

      https://www.ebay.com/itm/223107470864

      https://www.ebay.com/itm/253392799481

      https://www.ebay.com/itm/173532907146

      those are real bts hyyh autographed albums. if you want the legit album choose among them. price range is around 180 dollars.

      Delete
  76. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  77. Hello! I don't know if my previous message had been sent but I just wanted to know if these albums are truly signed? The seller is from Korea as it says and they have a website, (www.kpopmemorabilia.net) it shows how they are a trusted seller but I'm still unsure. They have multiple accounts on Ebay to sell their albums like chimyounki_0 and btsalbumskorea. Can you check if they actually sell authentic signed albums? I would really appretiate it! Thank you for all your hard work, it must be hard replying to all these messages. Please reply as soon as possible as the albums are up for a bid and it ends in a few days. Once again, thank you :)

    Here are the links:
    Website:
    https://www.kpopmemorabilia.net

    Albums:
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/EXO-THE-WAR-KOKOBOP-B-Ver-4TH-Album-Original-Hand-Signed-Album-CD-BOX-K-POP/183578375636

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/BTS-2-COOL-4-SKOOL-Original-Hand-Signed-Debut-Album-CD-GIFT-BOX-K-POP-KOREA/392192147669?hash=item5b507940d5:g:1okAAOSwwFNcBQci:rk:5:pf:0

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. All albums are fakes!!! I am really surprised that some people really fall for that kinds of scam. I felt sorry for the people who bids on those items.

      Delete
  78. Hi. I was looking around and I found these signed Lay promo albums but I think they look like they're either manager signed or fakes. They're going for a relatively low price and I was wondering on your opinion. They're from a seller on the good list if that really means much. If they are fakes I wonder if the seller has realized that. If they seem genuine then that would be nice to know as well because this would be a nice gift for a friend.
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/LAY-EXO-SHEEP-2nd-Promo-with-Autographed-Signed-/182880995172

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Just to clarify I'm not saying that your good list is inaccurate, or insulting it in any way, I'm just trying to bring in the point that not every seller is faultless and sometimes things slip through the cracks. I actually really support, appreciate, and follow the lists given here.

      Delete
    2. I think those albums are real! Although sm artists often have their staff or manager sign their albums, I think these ones are actually signed by Lay himself.
      handdollmaking is a very nice seller, who often warns if they think an album is possibly signed by the manager (although they sometimes dont/get confused themselves). I hope this helps!

      Delete
    3. Yes, I also think this signed album is real. Although it is signed in casual way and not in a complete style, still patterns and strokes are consistent with the Lay's real signatures.

      Delete
  79. hey i found this acc that sells signed stuff but i’m not sure if it’s real. i’ve always been skeptical of the shop but i’m not sure. they have good reviews though but it still seems weird to me. can you check it? https://shopee.ph/ahamoon.ph?version=11c580ddbba19e1691410393ab093121

    ReplyDelete
  80. Hi! Do you know anything about noblekorea on Ebay? I was looking at this album: https://www.ebay.com/itm/GIRLS-DAY-EVERYDAY-5-ALL-MEMBER-SIGNED-PROMO-CD-Photobook-Photocard-K-pop/202274333243

    It looks legit to me, but I'm unsure, thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  81. Has anyone had any experience with kpopstoreinusa9? They're also a physical store in Atlanta, Georgia. They occasionally sell autographed albums on their ebay along with their regular merch. I bought ONF's You Complete Me signed album from them. It was my first signed album that I ever bought, and at the time I didn't know much about promo albums. The ONF album arrived and the signatures look very legit to me when comparing them to the members' official signatures. But the album wasn't a promo album, and wasn't advertised as such. There's no 비매 or Not For Sale sticker on it. So I'm just confused as to how the store might have acquired it.

    They don't sell a ton of autographed albums. They have none for sale right now. Which makes me doubt that they're purposefully pumping out fake autographed albums themselves. But could I get someone's thoughts on this? If it's possible to still view the listing, it was here: https://www.ebay.com/itm/264031447656

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. After one on one comparison with other signed promo albums (https://www.ebay.com/itm/153235771577), I can confidently say that the above album is completely legit. There are lots of signed albums which are not promo albums. They can be Mwave, Meet & Greet, fan signed ones. Also, you might know that idols prepare their promo signed albums before their debut and distribute them to broadcasting staffs when they are attending TV shows or radio programs. However, sometimes they run out of their promo signed albums still they have attend more TV shows or radio programs. Even, some broadcasting staffs asks idols' managers to bring their signed albums before attend the program. Then, they just buy or get C1 albums instead and signed them and distribute them. Your case is the one I told you before because their position and pattern is so similar to signed promo albums which means that's the fan signed one. So, don't worry about your album. That's legit promo album even if it has C1 Mark on it.

      Delete
    2. I mean "that's not the fan signed one"

      Delete
  82. I don't think I can reply directly to your comment, but thank you so much for the helpful response, anon!

    ReplyDelete
  83. Don't buy from luxurygoods-kpop on ebay. Doesn't take responsibility for an item I bought and never received.

    ReplyDelete
  84. Good evening,
    I would love to buy an original signed album by Jonghyun (SHINee)/SHINee. It would mean a lot to me. Do you know a seller who sells original signed/handwritten albums by Jonghyun(SHINee)/SHINee?

    Best regards
    Nadine

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For Ebay Stores

      Buy From

      Mojasajo
      Hallyusuperstore
      KingofCarrotflowers
      Handdollmaking
      luxurygoods-kpop

      If they have any

      Delete
    2. https://www.ebay.com/itm/153427464246/

      https://www.ebay.com/itm/163613979722/

      They are super expensive but 10000% legit without a doubt.

      Delete
  85. Anyone ever deal with the seller kpopmemorabilia? They supposedly have a “Certificate of Authenticity” which claims they have each album stored within there datebase. Below is a link to a Blackpink album currently being sold. Personally to me these signatures look different from how I know them, especially Jisoos and Jenny’s signatures.

    https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F183787662426

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah taking a closer look at those signatures, they look way off. Calling it now that they sell fakes.

      Delete
  86. Hi, I've bought some promo albums from 100% trusted eBay sellers such as handdollmaking, hallyusupertore. I also read very carefully the guide post above and knew that seller the_king_of_carrot_flowers is only 50/50 trusted, and that most of SM albums are signed by the managers, but I'm interested in an EXO album: https://www.ebay.com/itm/EXO-2nd-Album-Repackage-Love-Me-Right-Autographed-Signed-Promo-CD-Great-Cond/173595295491?hash=item286b15ff03:g:bYwAAOSwcWJbyJlN. Can anyone who is EXO-L or knew their autographs very well tell me if it is legit, signed by the members, not their manager please? I really appreciate your help! Thanks a lot!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not 100% sure but looks legit to me since their strokes are a lot more sophicasted than manager's work. But still not 100% sure since I am not an expert about EXO

      Delete
    2. Look like a manager signed one :(
      there are very few real signed Love Me Right promo albums (so far I have only seen manager signed promos sadly). This is not the usual manager that signed during the Love Me Right era! It is the same manager who usually signs for the Overdose promos though.

      I have seen some real non-promo Love Me Right albums though

      Delete
    3. Thank you very much guys! I really appreciate your help <3 although it's sad to hear that the album isn't real autographed by the members :(

      Delete
  87. Hi, do you know anything about the eBay seller 7ki6382?

    ReplyDelete
  88. Do you think this album from seller kpop_music2 is legit?
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/BTS-Bangtan-Boys-LOVE-YOURSELF-HER-Autograph-ALL-MEMBER-Signed-KPOP/293099592531?hash=item443e18db53:g:HJMAAOSw0fdc5WuK
    If not what about this seller for an album?
    https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32863695327.html
    Thank you for your listing it definitely helped me not buy a bad product!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. kpop_music2 is a semi legit seller, sometimes they sell fakes
      The BTS album is real though!

      As for stray kidz, I am not sure as I am not familiar with them

      Delete
    2. KPOP_MUSIC2( smusic_ente0 the same people ) mostly sells fake when they sell some expensive signed albums such as NCT, Red Velvet, Twice, iz*one, BTS, Wanna One, Got7, EXO, Black Pink, etc. But that one is surprisingly legit.

      Delete
    3. That mixtape is absolutely fake. Compare with the legit one.
      I will give you a link.

      https://www.ebay.com/itm/153309816715

      Delete
  89. Hi does this look fake https://www.ebay.com/itm/BLACKPINK-JENNIE-SOLO-Album-Autograph-Signed-PROMO-ALBUM-KPOP/293100156479?pageci=a955e441-9b0c-41eb-81c1-41f4b1e13e23#vi__app-cvip-panel

    ReplyDelete
  90. Could someone take a look real quick? I asked the seller, and he said there was a C1 sticker on the back, with no 비매 or not for sale barcode.
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/Girls-Generation-SNSD-Into-The-New-World-Debut-Signed-Album/173865186003?hash=item287b2c32d3:g:rwgAAOSwpCFcqUUG

    Thanks in advance!

    ReplyDelete
  91. https://m.ebay.com.sg/itm/BLACKPINK-Signed-Autographed-Square-Up-1st-Mini-Promo-CD-Album-Photobook-card/183641933596?_mwBanner=1&_rdt=1 Is this legit????

    ReplyDelete
  92. Does anyone know this website "yncjswgoods.com"? They have low prices, blurry lq pics, free shipping?? The lack of google search results is especially concerning considering the huge variety of products they supposedly offer. This is half a question about whether anyone's bought from them and half a warning that this looks way suspicious, haha.

    ReplyDelete
  93. hi. I dont know if you're still around. but i saw gagagallery on aliexpress selling signed merchandise and i really want to know if its genuine or not

    ReplyDelete
  94. Can anyone help me out? I think a bunch of the signatures look legit but there are some (particularly Handong's) that don't look right to me. It's sold by smusic_ente0, so I'm not sure what to think. Thanks! https://www.ebay.com/itm/DreamCatcher-Alone-in-the-City-Autograph-ALL-MEMBER-Signed-PROMO-ALBUM-KPOP/254268528396?hash=item3b3395d70c:g:WnIAAOSwE8VbxA5r

    ReplyDelete
  95. Looking at this IZONE promo album, looks legit. Though I’d like a 2nd opinion if possible thanks!

    https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F293136439697

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If I were you, I would avoid this seller since he sells lots of fakes but yes that album is legit. Every signatures look right.

      Delete
    2. No, I guess some sigantures are incorrect. Especially, Hitomi. Actually, they distributed signed promo albums with one~two members are missing. I guess he fills some missing signatures.

      Delete
    3. (Original poster) Thanks guys, I’ve notice these look slightly different. Especially compared to a legit seller “Handdoll”

      Delete
  96. Ive just found a website but i dont know whether it is trustworthy or not. I intend to buy some iterms on it. However i dont know well about it. Please help me
    https://www.yncjswgoods.com

    ReplyDelete
  97. Hello, anyone knows if seller go-forture on eBay is selling real signed albums or not :) I'd really appreciate your help!

    ReplyDelete
  98. Hello~! Do you know where I can find an authentic Baekhyun signed City Lights album? Thx a lo!

    ReplyDelete
  99. Hey! You mentionned something about SNSD album with only one signature in silver pen and I ordered from one of these seller a bts signed album with the same thing but after looking really close to the album (i checked it a lot the day i recieved it and again some days later without looking at it during this time) and i checked with actual signatures and they are really looking like a true one so is it really legit? i'm really scared i sent a mail to them and they told me it was from a fansign or smth and now that i read your article im kinda scared since it's not the first time it happens... But i wonder why would they do this on multiple albums too? it would too be obvious ? im a little panicked sorry...

    ReplyDelete
  100. Hello there.
    Do you know I the shop luxurygoods-kpop is legit ?
    I think someone already talked about it but I can't find a precise answer.
    Thank you :)

    ReplyDelete